If we are still going to run with Master Looter this is how it will be done just so that there is no more confusion.
-If you have won something already and someone rolls against you who hasn't won anything yet then you defer to them.
-If everyone who rolls for a piece has won something then the item just goes to the highest roll as if no one has gotten anything.
-If you win a tank or healer specific item, that item still counts as an item you've won for the night. So your next roll will on an item will not count unless everyone rolling has all won something.
It's really plain and simple. It's called spreading the love. If no one likes this then I will start a DKP system.....no one likes DKP.